Very insightful comment. I had the same impression. I first saw it in a primitive YouTube version, then saw it with Anna Caterina Antonacci on DVD, and finally saw it live, in person with Ginger Costa-Jackson (a delightful production), and actually the more I saw it, the more I liked it. The Milan public was too harsh on Verdi when they booed it during the inaugural run, and it was a pity because as we know, he was depressed after the death of his wife and two children, and almost quit composition all together due to the failure of Un Giorno di Regno. Thankfully for us and for the history of the art form in general, once he set to music the Va Pensiero chorus, he realized that he was a good composer after all and came back with the gorgeous Nabucco.
Like you, I made a point of seeing all Verdi operas, and once I finished, my only regret was that... I no longer had a Verdi opera that was new to me, to enjoy as a fresh surprise.
Bookmarks