Bohème for me, then my next one is Tosca, but then I take a turn and like third and fourth two operas that most people don't rank as high: Il Tabarro, a nice short Verismo piece with a dark mood and interesting orchestration (very cinematic), and Gianni Schicchi, a very entertaining comedy, Puccini's only. I don't particularly care for Madama Butterfly, I like Massenet's Manon much better than Manon Lescaut, and again I don't particularly care for Turandot in spite of its impressive orchestration. I hate Suor Angelica, and find La Fanciulla del West just OK. La Rondine is OK too, with the messy alternative third acts. Acts I and II are better. Le Villi is a plesant minor work, I like it. Edgar is a so-so minor work.
Bookmarks